TO: Architectural Review Board Members
FROM: Gregg Harding, RPA, Historic Preservation Planner
DATE: 5/12/2022
SUBJECT:
title
313 E. Jackson Street
Old East Hill Preservation District / Zone OEHC-1
Roofing
end
BACKGROUND:
Nannette Chandler is requesting approval to retain the existing roofing materials on a new construction single-family residence. The new construction project was approved in December 2021 and included a silver standing seam metal roof. This product was also listed as a product in the building permit. However, an r-panel metal roof was installed. The r-panel metal roof was installed to match the other cottages in that area along Jackson Street which also have r-panel roofs. A public 311 complaint was issued in May 2022 notifying Inspection Services of the non-approved roofing material and a hold is currently on the permit. The applicant has also provided a list of other houses in Old East Hill with similar roofs.
An abbreviated review requesting approval for the r-panel was referred to the board in May 2022. That application and the reviewer’s comments are included. This packet contains several items which were provided by the applicant, by staff, and requested by the ARB abbreviated reviewer. These include the following:
- The abbreviated review referred to the full board and comments from the reviewer.
- The December 2021 final review documents for 313 E. Jackson Street.
- A list of existing r-panel roofs in Old East Hill provided by the applicant. ARB and permitting records for each were reviewed for reference.
- Documentation on a similar case which occurred in 2019 and at 314 E. Belmont Street for reference.
- City Council Special Meeting minutes from May 2019 regarding and appeal of an ARB decision at 314 E. Belmont Street.
Information on the 2019 review for 314 E. Belmont Street was requested since this was a similar case where r-panel roofing was installed instead of the approved material. The application to keep the r-panel was denied by the board and subsequently appealed to City Council who upheld ARB’s decision. This has been provided as reference.
RECOMMENDED CODE SECTIONS
Sec. 12-12-3(5)b. ARB, Duties
Sec. 12-3-10(3)a and b. Old East Hill Preservation District, Purpose and Character
Sec. 12-3-10(3)i OEHPD, Regulations for new construction